Your Trusted Diamond Jewelry Buyers
Benadato diamond buyers logo

Denver Diamond Buyers

What’s on page?

Denver, the Mile High City, is known for its stunning mountain views, vibrant culture, and thriving economy. But did you know that it’s also a hub for diamond buying and selling? Whether you’re inheriting a family heirloom, downsizing your jewelry collection, or simply looking to cash in on a sparkling investment, Denver offers a variety of reputable diamond buyers eager to purchase your precious stones.

But with so many options available, navigating the world of diamond buyers can be overwhelming. Fear not! This comprehensive guide will equip you with the knowledge and confidence to sell your jewelry in Denver.

Diamonds Buyers Denver

Where Can You Find Diamond Buyers in Denver, Colorado?

Denver offers a diverse landscape of diamond buyers, each catering to different preferences and needs. Here’s a breakdown of where you can find them.

Physical Locations:

  • Jewelry stores: Many established jewelry stores offer diamond buying services, often accompanied by consignment options. Look for reputable stores with certified gemologists on staff.
  • Gold and silver buyers: These shops primarily deal with precious metals but often buy diamonds too. They offer quick cash deals but might not provide the highest price for high-end stones.
  • Pawnbrokers: While not ideal for top-tier diamonds, pawnbrokers can be a quick option for immediate cash on lower-value stones. Consider reputable and transparent operations.

Online Options:

  • Online auction houses: Platforms that offers transparent auction processes where you can potentially get a higher price to sell your diamonds, but the process can take longer.
  • Diamond buying websites: Websites who does instant online appraisals and secure shipping, but you might not get the same level of personalized service as with physical locations.

Additional Resources:

  • Professional organizations: The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) and the American Gem Society (AGS) can help you find reputable diamond buyers in your area.
  • Reviews and ratings: Look for online reviews and ratings on platforms like Google, and Yelp to get a sense of other customers’ experiences.
  • Industry publications: Magazines like “Diamond Pro” and “JCK” can provide insights into the current diamond market and reputable buyers.

Where Can You Find Diamond Buyers in Denver, Colorado?

How to Sell Diamond Jewelry in Denver?


  1. Gather information: consider sell your engagement ring? Collect certificates of authenticity, purchase receipts, or any other documentation available for your jewelry. This helps establish provenance and increases value.
  2. Clean and inspect: Give your jewelry a thorough cleaning to showcase its sparkle and potential flaws. Minor scratches or repairs can be professionally polished for a better presentation.
  3. Research diamond market: Stay updated on current trends and approximate value ranges for similar diamonds based on carat weight, cut, color, and clarity. Resources like GIA and Rappaport reports can be helpful.

Finding a buyer:

  1. Consider your priorities: Do you prioritize speed and convenience over top dollar? Immediate cash might be available at pawn shops or gold buyers, while online auctions like Worthy offer competitive prices but take longer.
  2. Compare options: Contact at least three potential buyers, including reputable jewelry stores like David Ellis, auction houses like Worthy, and online platforms like James Allen. Get detailed quotes and compare fees, payment methods, and turnaround times.
  3. Get multiple appraisals: Don’t rely on a single valuation. Take your jewelry to different buyers for appraisals to compare and ensure fair pricing.

Negotiation and closing the deal:

  • Ask questions: Understand the buyer’s valuation process, fees, and any deductions for repairs or imperfections. Don’t hesitate to ask for clarification on any unclear terms.
  • Negotiate based on your research: If you feel the offer is unfair, politely counter with evidence of similar jewelry prices or your own independent appraisal.
  • Choose the right buyer: Consider factors like trust, transparency, and overall experience alongside the final price. Go with the buyer who makes you feel comfortable and informed.
  • Secure payment and paperwork: Ensure a safe and documented transaction. Receive payment in your chosen format and obtain any necessary receipts or certificates.

Get a Free Appraisal from Benadato Diamond Buyers

In-Store Appraisal:

  • Visit our showroom: Benadato has a location at 100 Fillmore St 5th Fl, Denver, CO 80206. Their expert gemologists can assess your diamonds on the spot and provide you with a free and accurate estimate of their value.
  • Schedule an appointment: While walk-ins are welcome, scheduling an appointment ensures a dedicated gemologist will be available to give you personalized attention and answer any questions you might have.

Online Appraisal:

  • Submit photos and details: Benadato’s website offers a convenient online appraisal tool. Simply upload clear photos of your diamonds and provide details like carat weight, cut, color, and clarity, if known.
  • Receive an estimated value: Within 24 hours, you’ll receive an email with an estimated value range for your diamonds.

Phone Appraisal:

  • Call our showroom: Benadato’s staff can also provide an initial appraisal over the phone. Describe your diamonds in detail and they’ll give you a ballpark estimate.

Benadato offers no-obligation selling. You’re free to walk away with your diamonds after the diamond appraisal, without any pressure to sell.

Why Should You Sell Your Diamond Jewelry With Benadato?

Why Should You Sell Your Diamond Jewelry With Benadato?

Here are some compelling reasons why you might consider selling your loose diamond jewelry with Benadato:

Expertise & Reputation:

  • Decades of experience in the diamond industry.
  • GIA-certified gemologists for accurate and ethical appraisals.
  • Strong reputation for fair prices and customer satisfaction.

Convenience & Options:

  • Free in-store, online, and phone appraisals.
  • Direct buyer with no middlemen, maximizing your payout.
  • Flexible payment options: immediate cash, consignment, or auction.
  • Secure and insured transactions for peace of mind.

Transparency & Trust:

  • Clear and upfront communication about valuation and fees.
  • No-obligation selling – you’re free to walk away with your diamonds.
  • Commitment to building long-lasting relationships with customers.

Additional benefits:

  • Convenient Denver location and online accessibility.
  • Positive customer reviews and testimonials.
  • Active member of reputable diamond industry organizations.

Overall, Benadato offers a safe, reliable, and potentially lucrative option for selling your diamond jewelry in Denver. Their combination of expertise, transparency, and convenient options can make the process smooth and stress-free, while ensuring you get the best possible value for your precious stones.

Of course, it’s always wise to compare options and do your research before making any decisions. But Benadato’s strong reputation and commitment to customer satisfaction make us a compelling choice for many diamond sellers.

We invite you to come to the wonderful city of Denver, to enjoy the magical atmosphere, the great restaurants, and the kind people

We are waiting to host you here at Benadato for business

We are located at 100 Fillmore St, 5th Fl. Walk-ins welcome or schedule an appointment at 1-888-625-0232 or via our E-mail [email protected]

<u><a style="color:#D2AA5C" href="">Yossi Benadato</a></u>

Yossi Benadato is the Co-Founder and one of the many diamond experts at Benadato. He is a second-generation diamond dealer who grew up in the industry in Israel

<u><a style="color:#D2AA5C" href="">Yossi Benadato</a></u>

Yossi Benadato is the Co-Founder and one of the many diamond experts at Benadato. He is a second-generation diamond dealer who grew up in the industry in Israel

What’s on page?
More Services for you
Sell Your Diamonds

Either its designer Engagement rings, Loose diamonds , or flashy diamond bracelets & necklaces sell your
jewelry to the most trusted buyer of Denver , Colorado.

We Pay Cash for Diamonds
Get in touch with us to sell any of your diamond pieces for the best value
We Pay Cash for Diamonds​