JEWELRY
I just had a great experience. Not only did I get the best value for the jewelry I was selling, but they also offered me the best price.
SELL YOUR JEWELRY
Whatever you're selling, you'll get the highest offer in Denver - appraised on the spot by a specialist.
SELL YOUR DIAMONDS
Selling a diamond, an engagement ring or a wedding ring in Denver? We buy loose diamonds and diamond jewelry of every size, grade each stone on the 4Cs in front of you, and pay the same day, in cash or by wire.
How It Works
Appointments are recommended, and walk-ins are welcome whenever we're not with another client. Or send photos and get a quote before you ever leave home.
Send a few photos and a short description online, or book a private appointment. Walk-ins are welcome whenever we're not with another client.
Our GIA accredited expert, or the specialist for your category, evaluates your item in front of you and explains exactly how we reach the number.
Accept the offer and get paid by wire, Zelle, Venmo, check or cash. No pressure, no hidden fees, ever.
We buy direct and resell ourselves, so more of the value goes to you — not to a chain of middlemen.
Most quotes come back the same hour, and you're paid the same day you accept.
Diamonds and gemstones are graded by Michael Nedler, GIA accredited since 1981. Gold, watches, coins and bags each get their own specialist, fairly and on the record.
You see the weights, the grades and the market rates. No lowball games, no obligation to sell.
In Their Own Words
Selling a diamond is rarely just a transaction. Here are the clients who let us share their experience - on camera and in their reviews.
JEWELRY
I just had a great experience. Not only did I get the best value for the jewelry I was selling, but they also offered me the best price.
GOLD
Yossi is straightforward, professional, knows what he’s doing, and he’s honest. That’s exactly what I’m looking for.
GOLD
I felt the value I received for my valuables was fair and even higher than I had estimated, and the whole process took less than an hour.
HONEST Reviews
Had a great experience with Jamie, she was so patient and is very knowledgeable of her work!
Yosso and others were nice people... welcoming and very accommodating to your needs.. would recommend it to be your first stop!
Great experience from start to finish. Very knowledgeable and professional. JAmie was great!
Very friendly and helpful with our family coin collection.
My whole experience was very simple and straightforward, which was just what I’d hoped.
I had a great experience working with Yossi at Benadato Trading Company. He gave me a fair offer for my diamonds and took the time to walk me through the entire process, explaining each step along the way. He was knowledgeable, straightforward, and easy to work with, and I never felt any pressure. If you're looking to sell diamonds and want someone you can trust to treat you fairly, I highly recommend Yossi and the team at Benadato Trading Co.
I had a great experience at Benedato. They were very transparent, and knowledgeable. Yosso explained everything to me and I felt confident in our transaction. Thank you!!
Jamie and Yossi are fantastic! What a great and efficient process. Everything is clearly explained and the value is great! Highly recommend.
Very professional and an overall great experience.
Honest discussion with charts to verify information. Offered education and was easy to work with.
Yossi and Jamie are so amazing. They were so helpful. Thank yall for the help.
Awesome experience, quick fair super professional
I sold my old gold jewelry to Benadato Trading Co. in Cherry Creek and would recommend them to anyone looking to sell gold in Denver. The evaluation was free, with no pressure to sell. The team explained the karat and weight of each piece and how the offer ties to today's gold price. I got a fair price and was paid the same day. Honest, professional gold buyers. Highly recommend!
Good business! Helped me out !
I had a great experience meeting with Yossi Benadato and his team. While we ultimately weren’t able to reach an agreement, I genuinely appreciated their professionalism, transparency, and willingness to negotiate. Yossi and his staff were welcoming, approachable, and a pleasure to deal with. Unlike some other local luxury watch dealers, there was no arrogance or pretentiousness—just a respectful, straightforward conversation. Overall, a very positive experience, and I would gladly consider doing business with them in the future.
Yossi was great to work with. He walked me through the process and explained exactly what my jewelry was worth and how that translates in the current industry demand. I would highly recommend doing business with Benadato.
Great service!
Sold my gold and the transaction was very quick and easy. Very friendly.
Yo así and team were amazing. They helped explain that process to my friend and how they evaluate Jewlery. Fair values, no pressure.: so happy I doing them.highly recommended!
Great experience!
Great team of knowledgeable folks who take the time to educate and provide honest and transparent offers. Thank you!
Amazing people! Walk you through the whole process and offer Top dollar!
Very personable and great to work with!
Excellent service
Straightforward, honest, well explained, felt at ease. Grateful for education. Smooth buying experience. Thank you!
Great company
Smooth and easy process. I would highly recommend. It felt comfortable and transparent to get a fair, quick deal
The People Behind The Counter
“I built Benadato Trading Co on one principle: treat every seller the way I'd want my own family treated. We show you the grades, the weights and the live market price — then we make our best offer. No games, no pressure. Just a fair, honest deal.”
Yossi Ben Adato
Founder, Benadato Trading Co

Why Benadato
Most people sell fine jewelry once or twice in a lifetime, and the first question is always the same: how do I know the offer is fair?
Our answer is to show you, not to tell you. Nothing at Benadato is quoted on a guess.
Your gold is read on an X-ray analyzer that gives the exact karat and alloy without acid or scratching. Diamonds pass through the GIA iD100, which separates natural stones from lab-grown and simulants in under two seconds, and through a Sarine scanner that measures cut and proportions to two hundredths of a millimeter. Coins and bars are verified through the metal, not just the surface. You watch every test, and we explain what the reading means for your offer.





Our LocatioN
Book a private appointment at our Cherry Creek office, or walk in whenever we're not with another client. One client at a time, expert service and our best offers in one location.
Why Benadato
Decades of experience, a no-commitment evaluation, and a direct buyer with no middle-man — so you keep more of what your diamond is worth.
GET A FREE APPRAISAL
Worried about the risks of selling jewelry? With trusted experts who have been in the industry for several decades and a no-commitment evaluation, we can put your mind at ease. The experienced staff at Benadato Trading Company will quote the best possible price for any of your unwanted jewelry — and can even bring in an unbiased third party to do appraisals if desired.
We are a secure way to sell your diamonds or jewelry in Denver, CO. Between loose diamonds, rings, bracelets, necklaces, and wedding jewelry made of sparkling diamonds, we are interested in everything, so your experience is hassle-free.
Our team is trustworthy, efficient, and includes some of the most experienced gemologists in the second-hand diamond market.
We use industry-standard techniques to value your old diamonds or jewelry and quote the best pricing — backed with documentation through the whole process. We also take the security of your items and finances seriously, because we believe in perfection at every step.
We have a simplified process with stringent policies for an exceptional experience selling or buying any jewelry.
We are the direct buyer, so you don’t have to worry about a middle-man, hidden extra charges, or commissions — which gives you the best price and experience.
Loyalty to our customers is one of our core values: we create long-lasting relationships and an underlying trust you never have to question.
FAQ
Appointments are recommended, and walk-ins are welcome whenever we're not with another client. One client at a time, in our private Cherry Creek office.
Appointments are recommended, because we work privately with one client at a time. Walk-ins are welcome whenever we're not with another client.
Every item is evaluated by the specialist for that category: gold and vintage jewelry by Jamie, larger diamonds and rare gemstones by Michael Nedler, GIA accredited since 1981, together with Yossi, watches by Yossi, coins by Keller, and luxury bags by Mor. Our offer reflects today's real resale market, and we show you exactly how we got there.
The same day, by wire, Zelle, Venmo, check or cash. There's no limit: we've paid from a few hundred dollars to seven figures for the right piece.
Yes. We meet with one client at a time in our private Cherry Creek office, and your visit and your items stay confidential.
Yes. We buy from anywhere in the world and ship items daily. Contact us for a shipping manifest and an insured FedEx label; once your package arrives, we'll call you with an offer within 1 to 2 business days and pay the same day you accept. The evaluation is free, with no obligation to sell.
See What's New