Trusted Diamond Jewelry Buyers
Fully Insured & Bonded 
Same-Day PAYMENTS
Honest and supportive of the selling process.
Sell Your Tiffany Jewelry
Your Tiffany jewelry is evaluated in-house by our own team in a private Denver office. You see how the offer is calculated and, if you accept, you’re paid the same day.
Trusted Diamond Jewelry Buyers- Fully Insured & Bonded
- Same-Day PAYMENTS
Tiffany Jewelry We Recently Bought
Trusted Diamond Jewelry Buyers
Fully Insured & Bonded
Same-Day Cash & Wire
Denver’s Trusted Jewelry Buyer for Over 30 Years
At Benadato Trading Co., your jewelry is evaluated in-house by our own team, led by Co-Founder Yossi Ben Adato, a second-generation diamond expert with decades in the trade.
Our In-House Evaluation Team
Yossi Ben Adato, Co-Founder, is a second-generation diamond dealer who learned cutting and trading from his father in Israel and has been trading in the U.S. since 2004.
Michael Nedler, GIA accredited since 1981, is our in-house gemologist. He grades the diamonds and gemstones in your jewelry and reviews larger stones together with Yossi, so your offer rests on two expert opinions, not one.
Gold and vintage jewelry are evaluated by Jamie, our gold and vintage jewelry specialist. Every piece is judged on its metal content, condition, craftsmanship, gemstones and today’s market value, and we explain each step as we go.
The highest offer
We buy direct and resell ourselves, so more of the value goes to you — not to a chain of middlemen.
Fast, minutes-not-days
Most quotes come back the same hour. Walk-ins are appraised and paid on the spot.
Certified expertise
Diamonds are graded in-house by Michael Nedler, GIA accredited since 1981, and gold by our own specialist, fairly and on the record.
Honest & transparent
You see the weights, the grades and the market rates. No lowball games, no obligation to sell.
HONEST Reviews
5.0★ Based on 157 Google Reviews
Easy smooth process. Very comfortable and easy meeting and fair pricing.
this place was amazing and super easy for me to sell a ring i will absolutely be coming back here again
Great place! Very honest!
Yossi and the team were very friendly and professional and offered me a very fair price for my piece. The whole process was streamlined and painless. Would absolutely recommend Benadato to anyone!
Yossi was great to work with and does a great job educating you through the process so you feel comfortable. Highly recommend!
I had a great experience here! They were fair, honest, and gave me a really good deal for my gold. The whole process was smooth, straightforward, and professional. I appreciated that they took the time to help me and made sure I was happy with the offer. If you’re looking to sell your gold and want a place that treats you right and offers a fair price, I definitely recommend them. I’ll absolutely be coming back in the future!
Very helpful team, great and fast service!
I came here to get some of my grandmothers inherited jewelry evaluated and it was an amazing experience! Yossi and Jamie were very kind and welcoming and they gave a very fair price for my pieces, definitely recommend to all!
Yet another amazing experience i had at Benadato Trading Co, I was able to get my grandma's vintage necklace made down to a shorter necklace and a bracelet! Not to mention they also helped me customize my wife's wedding ring. Definitely come down to Benadato Trading Co for anything jewelry!!
The owners are the nicest people. They took their time and they were very kind and patient. I highly recommend!
Straight shooters, which I appreciated.
Incredibly professional and knowledge. Great experience all around!
I had a wonderful experience at Benadato Trading Co. Yossi was friendly, professional, and very knowledgeable. Previously, I took some jewelry to a jewelry store and received a bid. I gave Yossi the same items, and his bid was higher, thus demonstrating his honesty. Not only did I feel comfortable the entire time I was there, It was an enjoyable and memorable experience. Highest rating.
Absolutely phenomenal service. The entire process was professional to a degree that you feel when you are shopping in couture stores. Yossi and his staff all introduced themselves, I felt comfortable, respected, and the offer was beyond what I even expected to receive. Tip: go to the elevator inside and go to the 5th floor!
Yossi and Jamie were incredibly knowledgeable and honest. Working with them was a great experience and will be back.
Thank you for the knowledge and the sell of my rolex
I had a great experience with Bendato Trading Company! I inherited some items and was referred here to see if I might be able to sell a few things. I had the pleasure of meeting the owner, Yossi, as well as Keller. Yossi was very knowledgeable, friendly, and took the time to walk me through the process, which I really appreciated. He made the experience comfortable and straightforward, and I felt good about my decision to sell some of my rings. I’m grateful for the time and guidance he provided. If I ever have other items I’m considering selling in the future, I will definitely be returning to Bendato Trading Company. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and friendly team to work with!
Very informative and fair, helpful staff.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I truly cannot say enough wonderful things about my experience with Benadato Trading Co., especially Yossi, Jamie, and their amazing coin expert (whose name I unfortunately forgot!). My grandmother recently passed away and left me a collection of jewelry, gold, and coins. I was still grieving her loss and had never sold gold before, so I honestly had no idea what to expect going into this experience. From the moment I walked in, I felt incredibly welcomed and comfortable. Before we even talked business, Yossi and I spent nearly 30 minutes chatting about AI and connecting on a personal level. That alone meant so much to me. It never felt transactional, and that genuine human connection made all the difference during an emotional time. When it came time to evaluate everything, Yossi and Jamie were absolutely wonderful. They patiently walked me through their entire process, carefully evaluated and priced everything, and explained how they arrived at their offers. Their transparency was incredibly refreshing, and not once did I feel pressured or obligated to sell anything. I ultimately sold nearly $8,000 worth of gold and walked away feeling confident, respected, and genuinely grateful for the entire experience. What stood out most wasn't just the fair pricing, but the kindness, honesty, and care they showed me throughout the process. Selling jewelry that belonged to someone you love can be emotional, and they handled everything with such compassion and professionalism. Yossi, Jamie, and the entire team have absolutely earned my trust. If you're considering selling gold, jewelry, or coins, I cannot recommend Benadato Trading Co. enough! Thank you all for turning what could have been an overwhelming experience into such a positive and memorable one.
I brought a diamond ring into Benadato Trading Co. about a month ago, after the company was recommended to me by an appraiser who had valued my ring and I had expressed interest in selling it. He said they would be very fair in the price they would buy it from me. Well, not only were they fair, but Yossi, the owner, and Jamie, Yossi's right hand lady were friendly, efficient during the sale and purchase, and very good at making me feel at home and at ease during my time there. I had taken my ring to another jeweler, before going to see Yossi and Jamie, who offered me much less, and a retail shop in the area whose jeweler also offered me considerably less. I urge anyone looking to sell jewelry to give Benedato Trading a call and I know you will walk away happy!
Fabulous people and honest! Thank you!
Yossi and his team were kind, knowledgeable, and honestly so much fun to work with. They were clear about gold values and the value of non-gold pieces we brought it, explaining things to us above and beyond what we expected. Would highly recommend visiting them if you have gold pieces you are looking to sell or value.
Very helpful in selling my ring!
Great service!! Fast professional and fare
Yossi is truly the best in the business. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience from start to finish. He took the time to explain everything about my ring, walked me through the GIA report, and clearly explained the pros/cons, and different options available to me. What I appreciated most was how straightforward and transparent he was throughout the entire process. He showed me what my diamond could realistically sell for on the open market and negotiated fairly with me until we were able to put together a deal I felt really good about. I trusted him with my ring while it was sent to GIA for about a week, and as soon as it came back, everything was completed exactly as promised and I was paid the remaining balance. The entire process was professional, transparent, and seamless. If you’re considering selling a diamond or fine jewelry, I honestly wouldn’t waste your time taking it anywhere else. Go see Yossi. He’s knowledgeable, fair, trustworthy, and genuinely exceptional at what he does. Highly recommend!
The customer service was amazing, they were very helpful and professional.
I recently had a piece of jewelry evaluated and sold to Benadato Trading Co. Everyone there, especially Yossi were extremely helpful, patient, and friendly. The whole process was easy. They took their time to explain everything to me and were extremely fair. I would highly recommend. Thanks Yossi!
Table of Contents
As one of the most iconic and beloved brands in the world, Tiffany pieces are known for their exquisite craftsmanship and enduring value. Whether it’s a classic engagement ring, a stunning necklace, or a delicate bracelet, Tiffany jewelry holds a special place in the hearts of many. Given the high demand for Tiffany pieces, selling your Tiffany jewelry can be highly profitable. With Benadato, you can trust that you will receive top value for your treasured items through a smooth selling experience.
What to Consider When Selling Your Tiffany Jewelry
Whether you’re interested in selling your engagement ring, your earrings or a necklace, you should follow these tips to ensure you get the best value:
Check Authenticity
Make sure your Tiffany jewelry is genuine by checking for hallmarks and any original packaging.
Tiffany & Co. pieces typically have specific markings that certify their authenticity, so keeping any original boxes, bags, or certificates can also help verify your item’s origin and increase its resale value.
Condition Matters
The condition of your jewelry plays a significant role in determining its value. Pieces in excellent condition definitely fetch higher prices. Polish out scratches and fix any broken parts to make your Tiffany jewelry more attractive to buyers, and if needed, consider having your jewelry professionally cleaned and repaired.
Get a Professional Appraisal
Getting a professional appraisal done is essential to understand the current market value of your Tiffany jewelry.
A professional appraisal will provide you with an accurate and detailed evaluation of your diamond’s worth. Certified appraisers have the expertise to assess various factors that contribute to the value of your Tiffany pieces, such as the quality of the materials, the craftsmanship, and the rarity of the design, so you can get a clear idea of what you should expect when selling your jewelry.
Know the Market
Understanding the current market is crucial when selling your Tiffany jewelry. Some designs or collections may be more popular than others, which can influence the price you can get. Research the current trend and check recent sales of similar items to see what buyers are paying. Knowing the market and timing your sale right, when the demand is high, can help you get the best possible price and ensures you don’t sell your valuable pieces for less than their worth.
Choose a Trusted Buyer
Selecting a reputable buyer is key to a smooth and secure transaction. At Benadato, we are known for offering fair prices and maintaining safe, confidential dealings. we provide a transparent process, ensuring you feel comfortable and confident throughout the sale.
Decide How to Sell
Consider whether you prefer to sell your jewelry in Denver (in person), or online. Online transactions can be convenient and reach a broader audience, while in-person appointments can provide a personal touch and immediate feedback.
Sell Your Tiffany Jewelry to Benadato
Benadato is a reputable jewelry buyer that specializes in purchasing Tiffany jewelry. With our expertise and commitment to excellence, selling your Tiffany pieces to us offers top-dollar for your jewelry, ensuring you receive a fair and competitive price for your items.
Our team of experienced appraisers have an in-depth understanding of Tiffany’s renowned craftsmanship, iconic designs, and current market value, guaranteeing you receive an accurate and fair assessment of your precious pieces.
furthermore, we prioritize the security and privacy of your information and transactions, providing peace of mind throughout the selling process. Whether you prefer the ease of online transactions or the personal touch of an in-person appointment, we accomodate your selling preferences.
Whether you have a single item or an entire collection, we are your trusted partner in selling your Tiffany jewelry for the best value and best experience.
Sell Your Tiffany Jewelry to Benadato in 5 Simple Steps
Selling your Tiffany jewelry to us is straightforward and hassle-free. Here’s what you can expect:
- Contact Benadato: Reach out to us to schedule a free consultation and appraisal of your jewelry. You can contact us via phone, email, or our online form. One of our knowledgeable representatives will gather information about your piece and answer any questions you may have.
- Secure Shipping: Send your jewelry securely to us for a thorough evaluation. We provide insured and trackable shipping labels to ensure your jewelry’s safe arrival at our facility.
- Expert Evaluation: Once we receive your jewelry, our specialists will conduct a detailed evaluation considering factors like age, condition, materials, and current market conditions. You’ll have our offer within 1 to 2 business days of your item arriving.
- Competitive Offer: We will then present you with a competitive, no-obligation offer for your Tiffany jewelry. We strive to offer you the highest prices in the industry.
- Prompt Payment: If you accept the offer, we will promptly pay you via your preferred method, by wire, Zelle, Venmo, check or cash. If you decline, we will securely return your jewelry at no cost to you.
Throughout the process,our friendly and professional staff will keep you informed and ensure a pleasant and efficient experience.
Ready to Sell?
If you’re ready to sell your Tiffany jewelry, we’re here to help. Contact us at Benadato today to request a free appraisal and no-obligation offer for your beloved Tiffany jewelry.
100 Fillmore St, 5th Floor Denver, CO 80206
Reviewed by
Yossi Ben Adato,
Co-Founder & Diamond Expert
- GIA (Gemological Institute of America), Diamond Essentials, 2014
- Institute for Diamond Studies, Ramat Gan: Course in Gemology, Diamond Grading & Evaluation, 2003
Second-generation diamond dealer who learned cutting and trading from his father in Israel. Trading diamonds in the U.S. since 2004 and buying from sellers in Denver since 2011, where he evaluates diamonds and luxury watches.
More Ways We Can Help
What Else We Buy
We buy more than Tiffany jewelry. If you have other pieces as well, we evaluate each one individually in the same visit.
