Your Trusted Diamond Jewelry Buyers
Benadato diamond buyers logo

Sell Watches

What’s on page?

Let’s face it, sometimes your watch collection grows faster than your bank account.

Maybe your tastes have evolved, or that limited edition diver just isn’t getting the wrist time it deserves. Whatever the reason, it’s time to let some of your timepieces go. But fear not, watch enthusiast! We’re here to guide you through the process of selling your watches without feeling like you’re getting lowballed at a pawn shop. So, dust off those chronographs, wind those springs, and get ready to make some time for new treasures.

Sell Your Watch to Benadato

Where Can You Sell Your Watch?

Deciding to sell your watch is one thing, but finding the right marketplace is another! Here’s a breakdown of your options, depending on the watch you have and what you prioritize:

For Luxury Timepieces:

  • Dedicated Watch Buyers: These online platforms specialize in luxury watches, and if you are looking to sell your Cartier, Rolex, Patek or Philippe –  They offer competitive quotes, secure transactions, and often handle everything from pre-paid shipping to expert appraisals. (Think Watchfinder, The Watch Box, or Worthy).

For a Wider Audience:

  • Online Marketplaces: Platforms like eBay or Chrono24 cater to a broad range of watch enthusiasts. You set the price and handle the listing yourself, reaching a potentially large pool of buyers. However, research and competitive pricing are crucial.

For a Quicker Sale:

  • Pawn Shops or Local Jewelers: This option offers the fastest turnaround, but you might get less than market value. It’s best for non-luxury watches where convenience outweighs maximizing profit.

For the Savvy Seller:

  • Watch Forums: Online communities dedicated to specific watch brands can be a great place to find passionate collectors willing to pay a fair price. Just be sure to follow the forum’s selling guidelines.

Remember: The best option depends on your watch’s value, your desired timeline, and your comfort level. Do your research before choosing a platform!

Tips For Selling Watches Successfully

  • Be the Watch Whisperer: Become an expert on your timepiece. Research the model, brand history, and any unique features. Knowledge builds trust and strengthens your negotiating position.
  • Pictures Tell a Thousand Ticks: High-quality photos are crucial. Take clear, well-lit pictures from multiple angles, highlighting the watch’s condition and intricate details. A blurry photo screams “avoid!”
  • Honesty is the Best Policy: Be upfront about the watch’s condition, including any scratches or blemishes. Transparency builds trust and avoids buyer headaches down the line.
  • Price it Right: Research similar watches on your chosen platform to get a realistic idea of market value. Don’t overshoot, but don’t undervalue your treasure either.
  • Become a Wordsmith: Craft a compelling description that goes beyond just technical specs. Highlight the watch’s story, its emotional appeal, and why it deserves a new home on someone’s wrist.
  • Patience is a Virtue: Selling a watch, especially a luxury one, might take time. Don’t get discouraged by lowball offers or initial slow interest. The right buyer will come along.
  • Be Open to Negotiation: While you should have a target price, be prepared for some back-and-forth. Respond to inquiries promptly and professionally, and consider reasonable offers.

By following these tips, you’ll transform yourself from a casual seller into a watch-selling maestro.

Preparing Your Watch for Sale

Verifying Authenticity and Ownership

Before listing your watch, take steps to verify its authenticity and establish yourself as the rightful owner. This builds buyer confidence and increases your chances of a smooth sale. Here’s what you can do:

For Most Watches:

  • Serial Number: Locate the engraved serial number on the case back. This unique identifier can be used to check online databases (provided by some manufacturers) or referenced with the brand for verification.
  • Receipt or Certificate: If you have the original receipt or a certificate of authenticity, include them in the sale. These documents bolster the watch’s legitimacy.

For Luxury Watches:

  • Brand Verification: Some luxury watch brands offer online portals where you can enter the serial number to confirm authenticity.
  • Independent Appraisal (Optional): Consider getting an appraisal from a reputable watch expert, especially for high-value timepieces. This adds an extra layer of trust for potential buyers.

Proof of Ownership:

  • Receipt or Bill of Sale: The original receipt or a bill of sale acts as proof of purchase, demonstrating you acquired the watch legitimately.

Cleaning and Maintenance Tips

Getting your watch ready for sale goes beyond just snapping a photo. A clean and well-maintained timepiece not only looks better in pictures but also assures potential buyers they’re getting a watch in good condition. Here’s how to give your watch some pre-sale TLC:

General Cleaning:

  • Microfiber Magic: Use a soft, lint-free microfiber cloth to gently buff the case, crystal, and bracelet (or strap). This removes dust, fingerprints, and everyday smudges.
  • Light Soap and Water (For Water-Resistant Watches): For stubborn grime, a mild dish soap solution can work wonders on a water-resistant watch. Important: Dry the watch thoroughly with a microfiber cloth after cleaning. Never submerge a watch that isn’t water-resistant!

Material-Specific Care:

  • Stainless Steel: A polishing cloth designed for stainless steel can add a touch of shine to the case and bracelet. Avoid abrasive cleaners that can scratch the surface.
  • Leather Straps: Leather straps benefit from a good leather conditioner to keep them supple and prevent cracking. Avoid using water or harsh chemicals.
  • Fabric Straps: Hand wash fabric straps with a mild soap solution and let them air dry completely.

Important Reminders:

  • Avoid Harsh Chemicals: Skip the jewelry cleaners, window cleaners, or anything else with harsh chemicals. These can damage the watch’s finish or gaskets.
  • Know Your Limits: For complex cleaning or repairs, especially on vintage watches, consult a professional watchmaker. They have the expertise and tools to handle delicate tasks without compromising the watch’s value.

Choosing the Right Platform to Sell Your Watch

Choosing the Right Platform to Sell Your Watch

Finding the perfect platform to sell your watch depends on several factors, including the watch’s value, your desired timeline, and your comfort level. Here’s a breakdown to help you find your selling sweet spot:

PlatformProsConsIdeal for
Dedicated Watch Buyers (e.g., Watchfinder, The Watch Box, Worthy)Secure transactions, competitive quotes, often handle everything (shipping, appraisals). Great for convenience and speed.Fees can be higher than other options.Luxury watches (Rolex, Patek Philippe, Omega, etc.)
Online Marketplaces (e.g., eBay, Chrono24)Reach a broad audience, set your own price.More work involved (listing creation, managing inquiries). Important: Research & competitive pricing are crucial.A wide range of watches, from vintage to modern
Watch ForumsPotential for passionate collectors willing to pay a fair price.Requires following forum guidelines, reaching the right audience might take time.Specific watch brands where there’s a dedicated community of collectors.

Remember: When selling a Rolex, prioritize platforms with expertise in luxury watches and a proven track record of secure transactions.

sell watches

Why should You sell Your watch with Benadato?

Is your watch collection overflowing like a spilled bag of M&Ms? Do you have a timepiece that deserves a wrist that appreciates its finer points, instead of being relegated to the back of your drawer (behind that embarrassing fruit-flavored candy necklace you forgot about)?

Look, I get it. We all have watches that whisper sweet nothings of “sell me” in the quiet of the night. But parting ways with a cherished piece can feel like sending your firstborn off to college (hopefully with a better return on investment).

That’s where we at Benadato’s steps in, my friend. We’re not your average pawn shop pushing yesterday’s news for pennies on the dollar. We’re watch enthusiasts who understand the soul (or at least the intricate mechanics) that resides within your timepiece.

Think of us as the matchmakers of the watch world. We’ll find the perfect new owner who’ll treasure your watch as much as you once did (maybe even more, because let’s be honest, how often did you wear that gold-plated monstrosity from Uncle Frank?).

So ditch the classifieds and the endless lowball offers. Let Benadato help your watch find its happily ever after (and get you a nice chunk of change in the process). It’s a win-win situation, unless of course, you’re secretly attached to that fruit-flavored candy necklace. We don’t judge here… much.

Absolutely! Here’s a different way to phrase the call to action for Benadato:

  • Visit our Denver location: We’re watch enthusiasts, not strangers! Swing by 100 Fillmore St., 5th Floor to chat about your watch in person.
  • Call us toll-free: Skip the email and have a conversation! Dial 1-888-625-0232 and connect with a friendly Benadato team member.
  • Shoot us an email: We answer emails too! Reach out to

    [email protected] and let’s get the conversation started.

Experience the Benadato difference – where your watch finds its perfect new home (and you get a great deal in the process).

<u><a style="color:#D2AA5C" href="">Yossi Benadato</a></u>

Yossi Benadato is the Co-Founder and one of the many diamond experts at Benadato. He is a second-generation diamond dealer who grew up in the industry in Israel

<u><a style="color:#D2AA5C" href="">Yossi Benadato</a></u>

Yossi Benadato is the Co-Founder and one of the many diamond experts at Benadato. He is a second-generation diamond dealer who grew up in the industry in Israel

What’s on page?
More Services for you
Sell Your Diamonds

Either its designer Engagement rings, Loose diamonds , or flashy diamond bracelets & necklaces sell your
jewelry to the most trusted buyer of Denver , Colorado.

We Pay Cash for Diamonds
Get in touch with us to sell any of your diamond pieces for the best value
We Pay Cash for Diamonds​